Today’s currency comes from famed Biologist and atheist, Richard Dawkins.  He recently began tweeting his thoughts on abortion concluding that a human fetus is less valuable than a pig.

Dawkins 2

This statement is meant to suggest a low view of fetuses in order to justify abortion.  While it is tempting to spend time on Dawkins’ thinking with respect to fetuses, specific attention will be focused on something else Dawkins said:

Dawkins

Here Dawkins refers to something he calls “consequentialist morality.”  Consequentialism is a form of ethics that involves making decisions based on what can be perceived as the most beneficial outcome of those decisions.  So, if a group of Americans were deciding whether or not to take a vacation in North Korea, they would be deciding based on what they perceive to be the better set of consequences out of the two choices.  This understanding raises some questions about what Dawkins meant when he said that a pig is more valuable than a fetus.  Clearly, a “consequentialist morality” cannot inform anyone of the intrinsic value of fetuses compared to pigs.  Dawkins first had to make an ontological decision that a fetus is not a human at conception (and, therefore all fetuses are exactly the same) before concluding that a pig is more human than a fetus.  Also, consequentialism as a normative ethic does not necessarily have to agree with Dawkins’ view on fetuses and abortion.  In other words, a consequentialist could consider society on the whole as having more value than the individual’s preference.  So Dawkins really hasn’t explained his view by appealing to consequentialism.

In light of this societal consideration, I responded to him below.  How would you have responded?

Dawkins Response

1 COMMENT

  1. Value is subjective. One person may consider a fetus of greater value than a fully grown pig. Mr Dawkins has no monopoly on truth. Objective observation would conclude that fetus and fully grown pig has no relationship to each other.

  2. It is truly a great and useful piece of info. I’m satisfied that you shared this useful info with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.

  3. Write more, thats all I have to say. Literally, it seems as though
    you relied on the video to make your point. You definitely know what youre talking about, why throw away your
    intelligence on just posting videos to your weblog when
    you could be giving us something informative to read?